In Defense of Non-sexual Nudity

© 2004-08 James H. Vipond

The Easy Breather and Minerva Walker share a twofold goal: to have non-sexual nudity legalized in the United States, and to eliminate cigars, cigarets, pipes and other forms of tobacco intended for human consumption. Find out why black Americans should be concerned about tobacco.

Ways to Legalize Nudity in South Dakota

  • One effective way to combat pornography, which is all too easily accessible to minors despite the use of blinders or opaque wrappers on newsstands, is to discredit the notion that certain human body parts are exclusively sexual. Another is to discourage the use of infant formula, thereby allowing young mothers to breastfeed their babies in public places.
  • Organize a public, non-sexual nude gathering with so many participants, both men and women, that the police cannot arrest all of them. It worked in 1936 New Jersey, when men removed their tops on the beach.
  • Write to your state legislators in Pierre (postal letters are preferred to email) and ask that non-sexual nude recreation be allowed in at least one state park when weather permits.
  • Better yet, run for the state Legislature and change the laws yourself.

Talking Points

  • Simple nudity is not prohibited anywhere in the Bible, but was a routine part of life from biblical times until the Industrial Revolution. Those who condemn public nudity as immoral are guilty of reading human opinion into the Word of God. As long as clothing was made by hand and not mass produced, only the very wealthy could afford more than one set of clothes.
  • Even Morality in Media recognizes that prohibiting obscenity will not lead to a fiat ban on nudity per se; see Clichés About Obscenity Law and the First Amendment, point number 7.
  • Clothing compulsion, especially in summer, is related to tobacco use in that both can be unhealthful: The former can allow growth of bacteria and other skin irritants, and the latter has been known to damage internal organs, even the brain.
  • Preferring that human nudity in a movie or television program, whether animated or with live actors, be implied rather than shown is not the same as stating dogmatically that all depictions of nudity violate the commandment against adultery.

Recommended Entertainment Review Sites

  • Christian Spotlight on the Movies: This site judges movies on both artistic quality and moral quality, but it does not display properly in Netscape 4.x browsers.
  • Ted Baehr’s MOVIEGUIDE®: To my knowledge, Dr. Baehr is the only named movie reviewer who distinguishes between sex and nudity. Only a Muslim, however, would be offended by “upper male nudity”.
  • Screen-It!: This site has both a content review and an artistic review for each film.
  • Decent Films Guide: This site grades movies on four scales, each for a different criterion.
  • PSVratings.com: This site uses a color- and shape-coded system, akin to traffic lights, to indicate the amount of profanity, sex and violence in movies. Under the PSVratings.com system, however, red does not mean stop and green does not mean go; if you want a movie that has nude scenes but no sex, no bad language and minimal violence, you would look for a white P icon, a yellow S icon and a white or green V icon.

Related Sites

  • Loxie & Zoot and its spinoff, The Bare Pit: To my knowledge, these Australian webcomics are alone in portraying everyday nudity without being sexually explicit.
  • Indecent Images: Alchemy Mindworks presents a gallery of pre-Raphaelite paintings whose online exhibition would have been prohibited if the Communications Decency Act had not been repealed.
  • The Big KiSS Page: This site features downloadable electronic “paper dolls” based on characters from both Japanese and North American popular culture. Some kisekae doll creators have integrated underwear into their basic figures, and others make no attempt to keep genitalia hidden.
  • McSweeney’s Internet Tendency: When may the upper body be exposed on TV?
  • Bikini Science Exposure Codes: This is a shorthand system for recording swimwear skin exposure.
  • CFI Naturist Guide to the Movies
  • Nudity in Science Fiction: Strangely, this page makes no mention of The Invisible Man by H.G. Wells.
The issue of human nudity — be it in drawings, in paintings, in digital art or in sculpture; on the beach, on television or on the silver screen — has caused dissension for hundreds of years, especially in the United States and the United Kingdom. But it took the Janet Jackson incident of February 2004 to get Congress worked up about the issue. I’m all for sexual restraint and I recognize the purpose of clothing. But I also believe that we are not to be ashamed of the human body, the pinnacle of God’s creation. We cannot hide our thoughts from God, so why do we try to hide our bodies?

I live in South Dakota, which in the summer can be as hot as Arizona. Several cities and counties in my state have by popular vote banned public nudity as a means of closing down “juice bars” that also featured nude female dancers. Such bans are overbroad, tantamount to burning down the house to roast a pig. South Dakota seems to be the only one of the 50 states that has no land set aside for nude recreation, so despite my acceptance of innocent nudity, I am unable to join a naturist group.

Nudity in entertainment should be accepted when it is relevant to the story, and not merely to shock or to provide sexual gratification. Even Cartoon Network has shown nudity in animation, particularly from Canada and Japan. Let us, for a moment, look at other kinds of media content many Americans consider to be objectionable:

  • Violent behaviors in entertainment need little explanation. Suffice it to say that most, but not all, media violence is uncreative and irrelevant to whatever story is being told. Obvious exceptions are war dramas and detective stories.
  • Foul language, such as obscenity and irreverent use of the Lord’s name, may seem harmless in that, unlike alcohol and tobacco, it does not addict or kill people. Vulgar speech does, however, demonstrate a general decline in civility. The same goes for coarse joking in comedies (Ephesians 5:4).
  • Stereotyping of people can be damaging when based on factors beyond human control, such as skin color, national origin or disability. Even occupational stereotyping is often unfair; for example, many lawyers are not corrupt or greedy.

At least one film critic condemns as sexually immoral not only actors getting stark naked (or nearly so) on the screen, even for a bath or shower, but also scenes of couples in bed. His rationale is that, in the first instance, because people must be clothed in public, actors must be clothed in the movies, and in the second instance, though the characters are husband and wife, the actors tend not to be married. This critic must not approve of the Blondie comic strip, in which Blondie and Dagwood are routinely shown in bed together, and Dagwood is just as often shown in the bathtub or wearing only either underwear or a sopping wet towel. Blondie herself has appeared nude at least since 1948, but always with her large, attractive breasts hidden by clothing, bath water, props or her own forearms.

Few years have gone by in the 20th and 21st centuries without at least one film or TV show that contained a nude scene. The ultra-restrictive Hays Motion Picture Code, which was in force from 1933 to 1966, forbade not only the nakedness of actors but also any visual indication of pregnancy. Some films, such as the 1940 production of The Invisible Woman with Virginia Bruce, defied the anti-nudity clause in the Hays Code. Even Walt Disney encouraged a 12-year-old boy to get naked on a rope swing while filming Pollyanna (1960). After 1966, when the churches stopped reviewing the content of every film, movies in general started to decline in quality.

In 1968, the Motion Picture Association of America introduced its age-based rating system, which persists to this day. A board rates movies for perceived age appropriateness, but the board members are not necessarily a cross section of parents in the United States. For me, nudity by itself can be sexy but is not sexual, and it is less problematic than aberrant sexual behaviors (including homosexuality), useless violence, glorification of alcohol and tobacco, foul language, discordant music, displays of tattoos and embedded jewelry (including earrings on men), disrespect for legitimate authority, or promotion of religion other than true Christianity. Regrettably, since 1966, most movies have been made by directors, writers and studio executives who show little regard for decency.

Dwayne Bell agrees with me that women should be admired as much for their intelligence and purposefulness as for their physical beauty. But can male nudity in entertainment ever be accepted as anything but comedic? Yes, if it is done in good taste and relevant to the story, and if the man is attractive to women but calls no undue attention to his naked body.

Should children be allowed to see adults or other children naked? Only a parent can answer that question, and only for his or her own children. I may not live to see it, but the day will come when everyday nudity is once again accepted in mainstream U.S. society.